Educating Consumers is a Tricky Business; Syms Files for Bankruptcy

By Paul Pannone

Just shy of two years since we lost Sy Syms, founder of Syms, his family filed for bankruptcy citing fierce competition in the worst economic environment since the Great Depression of the 1930′s.

In a Press Release, Syms CEO Marcy Syms said: “This has been a challenging time for Syms and Filene’s Basement. We have been faced with increased competition from large department stores that now offer the same brands as our stores at similar discounts; a proliferation of private label discount chains; a decline in buying opportunities as brand name labels have reduced overruns by improving their supply chain management – all combined with the worst economic downturn in our lifetimes.”

 

In less than two years of his death the slogan that Sy Syms created ultimately turned on the company he built.

 

 

The Syms slogan of An educated consumer is our best customer enlightened value-minded consumers that wanted designer apparel but not the cost may finally be proven untrue, now that sharp shoppers are no longer kept in the dark or fed filtered information from manufacturers and retailers. 

According to Matzav.com, “The off-price clothing that Mr. Syms sold on unadorned racks in large, no-frills stores, mesmerized customers who recognized prestige designer labels in the lining. Although not all of the attire was actually the same Pierre Cardin jacket or Brioni suit you’d find it Italy, it was good enough to satisfy bargain-hunting customers who needed a decent suit for a job interview, and it made Mr. Syms a multimillionaire.

In the Press release Marcy Syms cites the decreasing opportunity to buy up overruns and enable the company to undercut the competition, as manufacturers today better leverage technology to improve their systems and grow efficiencies. eWedNewz is following several stories of how old-run apparel companies plan to update their business and create products that consumers actually want instead of gambling on what they think consumers want.

One of the stories involves the renaissance of the tuxedo rental business. Accepted practices of recycling garments were always suspect to consumers wondering where the component items of the tuxedo rentals had been– and how often.  The concerns were often dismissed by tuxedo operators citing bowling shoes, hotel beds, public bathrooms, etc., that are cleaned, recycled and reused or “turned over”. But can anyone tell how many people actually sleep in a bed, or how many times a toilet seat is used, unless told? Even then, who does one ask for this information or the even greater question of does anyone really want to know?

In the case of outdated garments bearing branded labels like Christian Dior, reports by eWedNewz is sending shock waves through the tuxedo business that fought to keep such information from the public. What the narrow-minded of the business fail to realize is today’s consumer will find out the truth and simply abandon renting tuxedos, mailing letters or buying products from discounters like Syms and Filene’s basement because they can get better value elsewhere. Before you know it there is no longer a business.

What Syms did wrong was stay too long and not adjust to the changing market. They relied on overruns and seconds to sell, rather than change their model while there was still time. The words used as a slogan; an educated consumer– soon became their own worst enemy.

According to the Press Release, the Syms Corp was founded by Sy Syms in 1959. Filene’s Basement traces its roots back to 1909 and founder William Filene. Syms acquired assets of Filene’s Basement, Inc., which had filed for bankruptcy, in a bankruptcy auction in 2009. Syms Corp and Filene’s Basement, LLC collectively own and operate 46 “off-price” apparel stores located predominantly on the east coast of the United States under the “Syms” name (which, together with co-branded Syms/Filene’s Basement stores, are owned and operated by Syms Corp) and the “Filene’s Basement” name (which are owned and operated by Filene’s Basement, LLC).

 

 

 

eWedNewz

All Rights Reserved

2011

Tuxedo Stores Renting 10, 20 and 30 year-old Garments Are Killing the Business

By Paul Pannone

Reaction to an eWedNewz story involving the changes taking place in the men’s formal wear category struck a nerve yesterday bringing forward successful operators that say they’re suffering for the actions of their peers. The spotlight is on tuxedo rental stores carrying outdated merchandise, expired and fictitious brands, renting them to the public for premium dollars.

Since August a upheavel in the men’s formal wear business could be heading towards a showdown at the OK corral, as old– and we mean old– gets a kick in the pants by new products endorsed by today’s celebrities, including the Situation.

“At age 92, Cardin has certainly aged considerably better than his tuxedo label, but then again you can’t give tuxedos a little blue pill,” according to one formal wear retailer.

 

Fashion experts and strong supporters of tuxedos are coming forward to say they’re intrigued by the move to update the old standards with excitement and a new approach.

“A couple of images of The Situation can hold my interest for 90 seconds.  I may laugh at him.  I might make fun of him — but I don’t stop looking at the pictures.  In the end, I have to say that the images were great and I wish that I had abs like that.
The Calvin Klein commercial had all of the right elements — sexy people who are only partially dressed.  However, they were nothing compared with images of the situation.  They didn’t draw me in.  They didn’t make me smile.  They tried very hard to impress me.  I’m not the target audience.  I don’t believe that I was appropriately impressed. 

Yes.  The commercial was beautiful.  However, it didn’t hold my interest in the same way the The Situation does.  I didn’t even notice if the male model had abs,” said Jim Duhe.

Duhe, a 40 year fashion expert, says the tuxedo business is in serious trouble for many reasons. Duhe told eWedNewz the category gets no editorial support from his competitors but also puts the blame on the lack of innovation from tuxedo business itself.

“How do you expect fashion editors to get excited if the people in the business don’t have a story to tell?” he told eWNz. 

 In the statement Duhe includes manufacturers and retailers he feels have fallen short of delivering the right message to the consumer.

Sheryl Davies told eWedNewz, ” The tired old tuxedo rental turned off this generation of marrying males. They slid so far as to wear short-sleeved shirts, sneakers and nothing special suits. Now, they can outfit themselves and complement their brides, on their monumental day by again dressing with pizzazz. This is great news and maybe the nudge is good for the companies who have never changed their marketing tactics. I love the new styles and I love that tuxedos are back in the limelight. A tux says, It’s a special occasion.”

Davies, another long-time wedding expert, says she’s watching the current changes taking place in the wedding business and commends the proactive moves taken by some of the leaders in the formal wear business that speak to a new generation.

Formal Wear operators in New York look to major branded products like Calvin Klein and Ralph Lauren to lead the way to a comeback for tuxedo rentals.

NY Tux Girl says,”Being in the wedding business for over 21 years & doing tuxedos, I agree that the Calvin Klein and Ralph Lauren are great rentals for us. In New York guys like better quality and better fit (more) than what we had years ago. The super 100′s are the best quality we carry.”

So why are stores still supporting fictitious brands and carrying old styles? eWedNewz polled operators across the country that blame the lack of innovation from manufacturers over the past decade; certainly through the recession and declining use of formality in social events. Manufacturers in turn blame store owners for failing to update merchandise and not supporting new fashion. Meanwhile the standoff between suppliers and retailers can be heard in countless stories of misinformation in the marketplace. 

Market leaders like Jennifer Galletta writes, “ We had a lady call yesterday looking for the OLD Contour for her son that didn’t want to drive all the way out east (Long Island) to rent. She laughed and cursed the groom when I told her it’s 15 years old and couldn’t get them anymore. All she could say in disgust was Ew, I don’t want my child to wear that!”

 

Tony Commisso (far right) toasts tuxedos for providing a good living for his family. Commisso is giving back to his community and industry in so many ways. One specifically is buying new merchandise to give to his customers that have placed their trust in him.

 

The best response comes from Anthony Commisso in Latham, New York, that talked about 30 year-old Pierre Cardin tuxedos:

“I have witnessed two old-time father & son tuxedo operators in the Albany, New York area deceiving the consuming public. I have a firsthand experience where a client came rushing into my store pleading for our help in getting her son a replacement for a white dinner jacket for her son’s graduation ceremony. The mom showed me what they had rented from the other store this supposed white dinner jacket had yellowed so badly they shouldn’t even been able to pass it off for Ivory. The buttons were brown and brittle but it did have some signs of its glory days of old when the lining still had traces of white.

I looked at the tag inside and I thought how tragic, as I blurted out, “Pierre Cardin! This guy’s grandchildren are dead, that’s how old this coat is.” She gave me a quizzical look and I said “this coat is from the ‘80’s.”

I hooked her up to her delight and received accolades of her being eternally grateful. It was nice to hear but my hypothesis of most people’s true definition of eternally grateful, is the length of time it takes them to say eternally grateful. Anyway I hope the tux shop operators had that coat sent to the Cardin Family plot in Treviso, Italy.

At age 92, Cardin has certainly aged considerably better than his tuxedo label, but then again you can’t give tuxedos a little blue pill. The sartorial is in no way intended to offend Pierre Cardin or his family, just the tuxedo operators who still rent merchandise with a label and shelf life long expired,” according to Commisso.

 

 

eWedNewz

All Rights Reserved

2011

 

Calvin Klein, Ralph Lauren prop up Tuxedo Rentals

By Paul Pannone

The decline of formal weddings has taken the use of tuxedos to new lows in 2008 and 2009 causing the failure of several formal wear suppliers including the largest, After Six, leaving three suppliers: FLOW, Fabian Couture and Formal Wear International. But with the faster decline in consumer demand sources still say there is an overage of supply.

Recently tuxedos– an updated version– that depart from the traditional, are causing a stir, attracting attention of consumers. But the stir and what appeals to a segment of the consumer market leaves a traditional segment of the tuxedo business unhappy. It’s the segment that wants business to return to the glory days when a basic black tuxedo, a white pleated wing-collar shirt, bow tie and a vest allowed store owners to charge $150 dollars a rental.

The golden goose went on week after week, month after month, year after year for decades. An eWedNewz investigation shows some of the remaining companies are still renting tuxedo units they bought in the 1990′s– and even the 1980′s.

Names like After Six, Claiborne, Christian Dior, Raffinatti, Henry Grethal and the worst we’ve seen, Pierre Cardin? offer little or no value to the consumer. Outdated fit, incorrect lapel sizes besides unsanitary reasons give tuxedo rentals a bad reputation. By the way, Pierre Cardin tuxedos are from the 1980′s.

So what tuxedo brands are fresh, current and renting? fictitious names like Jean Yves are widely distributed, along with “B” labels like Perry Ellis. Most rent for about $125-150 dollars, depending on the area, and are perfectly fine. For about the same price names like Calvin Klein and Ralph Lauren are widely available only at better men’s formal wear specialists. But what if brands like Calvin Klein and Ralph Lauren no longer existed?

 

The 2012 Calvin Klein Sire is getting the greatest attention by consumers online.

 

Discussions with formal wear specialists say the most often “turned” brands in their stores are either Ralph Lauren or Calvin Klein. In major metropolitan areas turn percentages of over 40% are reported, dominated by the brands that are easily identified by consumers.

eWedNewz has learned the brands are vital to major retailers like Men’s Wearhouse that dominate the rental market, holding 33% of all the tuxedos rented in the US. An ongoing investigation as to why the Men’s Wearhouse rental division continues to grow shows the proper leveraging of better branded products like Ralph Lauren and Calvin Klein. Men’s Wearhouse capitalizes on their own marketing and advertising but adds the built-in brand awareness of the world-class names.

Beside the consumer brand recognition, superior fit and fabrics used in the manufacturing of the garments surpass the scratchy wool used in no-name and fictitious branded goods.

eWedNewz is watching the quiet boycott of the branded goods by operators could be coming to an end. Since 2003, many shied away from manufacturers that sold goods to Men’s Wearhouse but discovered they shot themselves in the foot, leaving the door wide open for Men’s Wearhouse and other competitors that embraced the brands.

In the eWNz investigation we’ve found the companies that carry old merchandise– Pierre Cardin?– have struggled to survive; most have disappeared. Those that are hanging on by a thread have stopped buying new goods or resist the demand of consumers and substitute inferior products.

Companies that caught on and included true brands like Calvin Klein and Ralph Lauren say they’re able to raise average ticket prices from 5-15% on each rental– far outpacing the additional cost of the garment.

What is your opinion? Please post it here or contact Paul@ewednewz.com or 516-312-0090.

 

eWedNewz

All Rights Reserved

2011